Quotient by subgroup is well defined if and only if subgroup is normal

https://arbital.com/p/quotient_by_subgroup_is_well_defined_iff_normal

by Patrick Stevens Jun 17 2016 updated Jun 20 2016


Let G be a Group and N a Normal subgroup of G. Then we may define the quotient group G/N to be the set of left cosets gN of N in G, with the group operation that gN+hN=(gh)N. This is well-defined if and only if N is normal.

Proof

N normal implies G/N well-defined

Recall that G/N is well-defined if "it doesn't matter which way we represent a coset": whichever coset representatives we use, we get the same answer.

Suppose N is a normal subgroup of G. We need to show that given two representatives g1N=g2N of a coset, and given representatives h1N=h2N of another coset, that (g1h1)N=(g2h2)N.

So given an element of g1h1N, we need to show it is in g2h2N, and vice versa.

Let g1h1ng1h1N; we need to show that h12g12g1h1nN, or equivalently that h12g12g1h1N.

But g12g1N because g1N=g2N; let g12g1=m. Similarly h12h1N because h1N=h2N; let h12h1=p.

Then we need to show that h12mh1N, or equivalently that ph11mh1N.

Since N is closed under conjugation and mN, we must have that h11mh1N; and since pN and N is closed under multiplication, we must have ph11mh1N as required.

G/N well-defined implies N normal

Fix hG, and consider hnh1N+hN. Since the quotient is well-defined, this is (hnh1h)N, which is hnN or hN (since nN=N, because N is a subgroup of G and hence is closed under the group operation). But that means hnh1N is the identity element of the quotient group, since when we added it to hN we obtained hN itself.

That is, hnh1N=N. Therefore hnh1N.

Since this reasoning works for any hG, it follows that N is closed under conjugation by elements of G, and hence is normal.